Log in
Search
Latest topics
» Anderson Baby Spitfire - looking for the aft tank and gasketby Boats13 Today at 8:18 pm
» Fuel residue stain clening help
by akjgardner Today at 7:53 pm
» my attempt at making an exhaust throttle for Cox .049
by roddie Today at 7:00 pm
» Another of C.T. engines cleaned ---- Cox Tee Dee .09 --- Just today (3/26/2024) more Cox parts
by sosam117 Today at 5:55 pm
» Cox powered boat litle shrimp hidroplane
by davidll1984 Today at 2:52 pm
» Introducing the new - "QZ" RR-1
by roddie Today at 1:08 pm
» STUKA bomb dimentions needed
by latole Today at 9:36 am
» Indexing COX cylinders
by davidll1984 Today at 7:56 am
» Introducing our Cox .049 TD Engines
by Yabby Today at 6:33 am
» 1/2a Skyray plans?
by 944_Jim Yesterday at 10:14 pm
» Postage stamp backplates
by JPvelo Yesterday at 8:52 pm
» Cosmic Winds, - Big Guy, Little Guys, Silver Guy and Wounded Guy.
by rsv1cox Yesterday at 5:18 pm
why resieze a prop ??
Page 1 of 1
why resieze a prop ??
I have heard a lot I talk about resizing perfectly good props ? to a smaller state of being for more RPMs ? And I am wondering what is wrong with using a smaller prop with more or less pitch //// What is the advantage !?!?
getback- Top Poster
-
Posts : 10028
Join date : 2013-01-18
Age : 66
Location : julian , NC
Re: why resieze a prop ??
Eric, many times your faced with a prop that just loads the engine a little more than you would like. I clip props to trade off speed for rpm's. Seeing that one of my events utilizes a criteria in which I can't exceed a certain mph adjusting prop sizes is the way to do it. If I chose to drop in inches or in pitch, my fuel economy suffers as a result of doing so and it's imperative that I have enough fuel to make it to the 5 minute mark. The same can be said in regards to flying stunt. A square tip Master Airscrew is less effective due to the tip vs a curved APC. Reworking a Master Airscrew prop to the shape of a APC will increase the effectiveness of the prop. Cutting down a prop can slow a plane down as I mentioned above or it can also increase speed due to the engine being allowed to run in the best part of its torque curve.
The only way to know what your doing is beneficial is by timing it and documenting it. I've done just that and I know what works. For example on my Norvel's I use on my 1/2A's, I could use a stock Cox 5x3 but it has a fair amount of blade area and it loads the rpm's in the maneuvers when pulling a streamer. I start cutting the prop down 1/4" at a time until the engine doesn't load and still utilizes a good amount of drive. I usually run a 3 3/4"- 4 1/4" prop on my Norvel's. Think of the engine as if it's running in 2nd gear opposed to lugging uphill in 4th.
The only way to know what your doing is beneficial is by timing it and documenting it. I've done just that and I know what works. For example on my Norvel's I use on my 1/2A's, I could use a stock Cox 5x3 but it has a fair amount of blade area and it loads the rpm's in the maneuvers when pulling a streamer. I start cutting the prop down 1/4" at a time until the engine doesn't load and still utilizes a good amount of drive. I usually run a 3 3/4"- 4 1/4" prop on my Norvel's. Think of the engine as if it's running in 2nd gear opposed to lugging uphill in 4th.
Ken Cook- Top Poster
- Posts : 5414
Join date : 2012-03-27
Location : pennsylvania
Re: why resieze a prop ??
I guy told me years ago, or maybe I read it someplace: Diameter for RPM, pitch for speed. Keep that in the back of your head when picking a prop for your engine/airframe.
Also remember pitch is an average of the prop, if you cut down a 7"x3" prop and inch, you do not have a 6"x3", but a higher pitch, a 1/2" on a 10" prop is not going to change much, but 1/2" on a 6" would.
Also remember pitch is an average of the prop, if you cut down a 7"x3" prop and inch, you do not have a 6"x3", but a higher pitch, a 1/2" on a 10" prop is not going to change much, but 1/2" on a 6" would.
Why re-size a prop
Hi Eric,
The main reason for cutting down prop diameter, is because an "ideal size" prop doesn't exist. There is nothing wrong with using a smaller prop with more pitch ...IF you can find one. In many cases, us modelers do not know what the ideal pitch to diameter ratio is supposed to be for a given application. I know I don't. I only have a best guess estimate. I have seen speed prop calculations done by an aeronautical professional. For the most part, it is beyond me, so the 'cut & try' method, based on best guess is all we have left... The major factor 'best guess' is based on is at what RPM your engine sounds happiest.
Shown is an array of props for Vintage Speed. All turn in a a similar RPM range, but have different pitch-diameter & blade areas. Only my stopwatch can tell for sure...
-
Cheers, Paul
The main reason for cutting down prop diameter, is because an "ideal size" prop doesn't exist. There is nothing wrong with using a smaller prop with more pitch ...IF you can find one. In many cases, us modelers do not know what the ideal pitch to diameter ratio is supposed to be for a given application. I know I don't. I only have a best guess estimate. I have seen speed prop calculations done by an aeronautical professional. For the most part, it is beyond me, so the 'cut & try' method, based on best guess is all we have left... The major factor 'best guess' is based on is at what RPM your engine sounds happiest.
Shown is an array of props for Vintage Speed. All turn in a a similar RPM range, but have different pitch-diameter & blade areas. Only my stopwatch can tell for sure...
-
Cheers, Paul
getback wrote:I have heard a lot I talk about resizing perfectly good props ? to a smaller state of being for more RPMs ? And I am wondering what is wrong with using a smaller prop with more or less pitch //// What is the advantage !?!?
Last edited by Paulgibeault on Sun Nov 16, 2014 5:21 am; edited 1 time in total
Paulgibeault- Gold Member
- Posts : 259
Join date : 2011-09-24
Location : Leduc, Alberta Canada
Why re-size a prop
Hi Mark,
I believe you are correct. " Diameter for RPM, pitch for speed". I am convinced that you can't really go fast without enough pitch. Of course in order to swing the big(er) pitch, you need to have a small(er) diameter, small(er) blade area & thinner blade(s). Your statement "pitch is an average of the prop" assumes the pitch is helical...which it may not be. A pitch gauge is the final arbiter in cases like this, & often shows up surprises.
Then there is the engine power curve side of things. Some engines can swing a heavy prop & TORQUE around the circle. Others need to swing a light prop & REV their way around the circle. (Some have an in between combination) I have seen both combinations work well & so it all comes down to prop matching for a given use. The record holders & podium finishers are generally the ones who get it close. When you see somebody being lent a prop & he goes WAY FASTER & his engine sounds COMPLETELY DIFFERENT, then you know right away he was using the wrong prop all along...
Famous (true) saying: " It's ALL in the prop & half in the engine."
Cheers, Paul
I believe you are correct. " Diameter for RPM, pitch for speed". I am convinced that you can't really go fast without enough pitch. Of course in order to swing the big(er) pitch, you need to have a small(er) diameter, small(er) blade area & thinner blade(s). Your statement "pitch is an average of the prop" assumes the pitch is helical...which it may not be. A pitch gauge is the final arbiter in cases like this, & often shows up surprises.
Then there is the engine power curve side of things. Some engines can swing a heavy prop & TORQUE around the circle. Others need to swing a light prop & REV their way around the circle. (Some have an in between combination) I have seen both combinations work well & so it all comes down to prop matching for a given use. The record holders & podium finishers are generally the ones who get it close. When you see somebody being lent a prop & he goes WAY FASTER & his engine sounds COMPLETELY DIFFERENT, then you know right away he was using the wrong prop all along...
Famous (true) saying: " It's ALL in the prop & half in the engine."
Cheers, Paul
Mark Boesen wrote:I guy told me years ago, or maybe I read it someplace: Diameter for RPM, pitch for speed. Keep that in the back of your head when picking a prop for your engine/airframe.
Also remember pitch is an average of the prop, if you cut down a 7"x3" prop and inch, you do not have a 6"x3", but a higher pitch, a 1/2" on a 10" prop is not going to change much, but 1/2" on a 6" would.
Last edited by Paulgibeault on Sun Nov 16, 2014 5:20 am; edited 1 time in total (Reason for editing : grammar)
Paulgibeault- Gold Member
- Posts : 259
Join date : 2011-09-24
Location : Leduc, Alberta Canada
Re: why resieze a prop ??
Answers from the pros That is great stuff , Thanks Ken, Paul and Mark for you input . I understand better the purpose now , ben wanting to try some resizing and comparing but did not know what I was looking for out of it . ( to make a more happy running engine for the application ) and get the most from that engine is what I am gathering . Eric
getback- Top Poster
-
Posts : 10028
Join date : 2013-01-18
Age : 66
Location : julian , NC
Re: why resieze a prop ??
All the things mentioned above are very true, one thing left out was sometimes you break your last prop right before you go out to the field, cutting one down on the fly may keep you going.
Keep in mind when you trim a prop it must be re-balanced. There are ways of taking of equal amounts off the blade, but it still needs to be balanced.
Ron
Keep in mind when you trim a prop it must be re-balanced. There are ways of taking of equal amounts off the blade, but it still needs to be balanced.
Ron
Cribbs74- Moderator
-
Posts : 11892
Join date : 2011-10-24
Age : 50
Location : Tuttle, OK
Why re-size a prop
Hi Ron,
Absolutely correct. At the field I've been known to trim Cox props with a toe nail clipper! My carbon props seem to have a short life & the higher the prop's performance, the more likely it is to get damaged or broken!! ARG!
Cheers, Paul
Absolutely correct. At the field I've been known to trim Cox props with a toe nail clipper! My carbon props seem to have a short life & the higher the prop's performance, the more likely it is to get damaged or broken!! ARG!
Cheers, Paul
Cribbs74 wrote:All the things mentioned above are very true, one thing left out was sometimes you break your last prop right before you go out to the field, cutting one down on the fly may keep you going.
Keep in mind when you trim a prop it must be re-balanced. There are ways of taking of equal amounts off the blade, but it still needs to be balanced.
Ron
Paulgibeault- Gold Member
- Posts : 259
Join date : 2011-09-24
Location : Leduc, Alberta Canada
Re: why resieze a prop ??
Lol, I'll second the toenail clipper, I've had one in my flightbox for years!
Similar topics
» [The Traveling Prop] Who wants to be the one to send the prop overseas?
» Cox Prop Rod
» Prop rod....
» if it has a prop.. it must be fun..
» cox 4x2.5 prop?
» Cox Prop Rod
» Prop rod....
» if it has a prop.. it must be fun..
» cox 4x2.5 prop?
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum